I have been watching American Idol for a long time and I find the Judges entertaining as well as the contestant's performance. Among the four of them, Paula Abdul is the one I like most. She is very sweet and it seems that she really cares for them. She knows that the contestants are just starting and trying to pursue their dreams.
| Community Home | Members | Headshots | Showreels | Voicereels | Blogs | Groups | chat | Forums |
Forums
SearchWho is your favorite Idol Judge?
- Message
MIne is Paula Abdul too. She seems so real and I feel her when she gives her comments on the contestants. And when they sing, she really gets into it and even stands up just to groove with the music.
The one I like is Simon Cowell. He tells the contestants his true feelings about their performances. I'm not saying that the other judges are lying to the them, Simon is just more straightforward. He tells them what he's got to tell them, no sweet words, and "I like you, ,,but, but" stuff. He is direct to the point. If he likes it, he likes it. if he doesn't, then he doesn't.
Kara Dioguardi and Randy Jackson are the ones I like. MOst of the times, their comments are the same as mine. They don't get emotionally attached to the contestants when they give their comments. I mean, it's obvious they feel for the contestants but they are not like Paula who (I don't mean to offend those who like her..) often gives comments tearfully.
I like Kara Dioguardi. I find her an elegant judge. American Idol made the right decision when they included her in the show as the fourth judge. She help keeps the balance i the judges especially when Paula and Simon gets into arguing, at least this time, Randy has company on the other side of the judges table. :)
Paula may be emotional at times but that's the thing I like about her. She means what she says, she is always sincere. That's a good quality for a judge.
It appears I'm the only one who likes Simon Cowell here. Well, I thought that would be the case. People think that he's just being mean and that he likes being that way. Well, he could be mean at times but I think he just wants to encourage the contestants to improve more and try harder.
Personally, I don't hate Simon. I just like Kara and Randy more. I also think that Simon makes the show more interesting, because of his usual criticisms.
Mine is Simon, he lets people know whats what. Its harsh to be told the honest truth but he prevent people from wasting their time sorta to speak.
I like Randy JAckson, he seems very down to earth. Not to mention everyone seems to respect him and his descision.
Kara DioGuardi all the way. She is so fair and honest; I think they should keep her and replace her with Paula Abdul. It seems like Paula has seen one too many auditions, and I think it's getting to her judgement. I think Paula bases her opinions off of looks, and not soul. Kara is fair and it seems like she sees the whole picture; I think Simon is too into himself.
I like them all! They are all so professional and great. I don't they should get rid of anyone; and I don't actually know if they are. They all do such a fantastic job. I think Paula is the comic relief; she is so cute! I admire what she does, and I think that Kara might be a little too stuck up; but otherwise, I like them all individually.
Simon all the way! Hes a hope crusher but he knows what hes talking about. He is brittish which makes him even cooler in my book.





